Tuesday, 1 January 2013


The Catholic Vote and Conscience -1

A Fr John Hogan in his blog ‘Ex Umbris Et Imaginibus’ dated Dec 31 2012 titled ‘Life is Precious’ - I quote just one of the paragraphs below – on reading it made me think more on the relationship which conscience has to The Catholic Vote. I like Fr Hogan’s blog as he seems to be one of the rare priests who has an instinct on how faith is linked with our world view and so in turn affects our influence in the Public Square.  Fr John is not at all a political blogger but he blogs on current events and mixes an astute spiritual, philosophical and political analysis in ordinary discussion. His blogs are for the most part spiritual in tone.

Start quote-

“If you can get a copy of January's Alive newspaper, my friend Fr Owen Gorman has an excellent article on conscience. He points out, correctly, that the Taoiseach, in imposing the party whip on this issue, is expecting his TDs to relinquish their conscience in order to "vote in accordance with party decisions". Yet, Fr Owen points out, "Each person owes greater allegiance to conscience than to any political party, yet this government says no accommodation will be given to conscience." This "highlights the sickness and dysfunction at the heart of Irish political life". This is, of course, ironic, given that Enda Kenny accused the Vatican of being sick and dysfunctional - at least the Vatican recognises the importance of conscience even in those who disagree with Church teaching. ”

 –End quote

[For those who are not familiar with Irish political terms or other terms mentioned in the above article. ‘Alive’ is a beloved Catholic News paper printed monthly and very useful for evangelising in our times. ‘Taoiseach’ is equivalent to Prime Minister. ‘TD’s’ refers to elected politicians to parliament. ‘Party Whip’ refers to when the leaders of a party insist that those members who do not support the party view must lose their position in the party.]

As you can see from the quoted piece Fr John is referring to a real life and current situation in Irish Politics. It is obvious we have the same squalid political principles in government  as any of our European or American political institutions. In general in politics one is expected to leave ones conscience aside and in particular one must leave one’s Catholic Conscience aside. Its the leaving aside of the catholic conscience that I take issue with here. The reason I say this is that it is precisely catholic conscience that should inform The Catholic Vote. These two are pivotal, both the vote and the conscience that forms it.

Lets have a quick look at conscience or what it is that we mean by conscience. By Conscience here in this discussion I mean a practical and important choice for a good based on the truth. For example if a referendum existed for to approve the sale of contra-ceptives – do I vote for or against? Here is the crux of the matter upstream from both conscience and vote namely – TRUTH. So when our estranged Taoiseach would ask that politicians refrain from using their consciences he is saying that they must not make a choice based on truth. That is after all what use of conscience is - namely a practical choice for truth. But suppose the alternative to choosing truth is choosing a lie. Then what? – well we have our anti-truth Taoiseach enforcing the voting for a lie.

Conscience of course must be formed. To be formed it needs to be informed. It must be informed by the truth. For Catholics THE TRUTH is of course A PERSON. That PERSON IS none other than the PERSON OF CHRIST WHO IS THE SECOND PERSON OF GOD. For Catholics GOD IS THE TRUTH and the Catholic Church interprets HIS truth through the teaching authority the Magisterium. So I agree with the American Archbishop Charles J. Chaput when he pretty much says that the greatest service we do for political life is to evangelise and live our catholic faith. For in doing so we form others in truth in their consciences. They are then better positioned to use their consciences to vote for truth. From among the voters for truth will come politicians for truth who will also form political parties for truth. I firmy believe after some years of experience that politics is extremely inefficient as a means to  change society for the better. What is required is to evangelise the culture. It is from the evangelised culture that an evangelised politics and evangelised politicians will emerge. I will concede that it is a really slow process but is alot more efficient in getting  politics to work for truth.

 

 

Development of understanding of The Catholic Vote so Far

So far we have found that:-

·         That there exists a consciousness of the existence of such a thing as the ‘Catholic  Vote’, especially in the USA where it has been heightened by the 2012 election of Obama.

·         That as a bare minimum it involves giving honour to GOD.

·         That it can involve a choice between GOD and State.

·         That it can involve voting against anti GOD legislation put forward by the State.

Thursday, 6 December 2012


SHOULD THE STATE LEGISLATE AGAINST NATURAL LAW -1

The King's good servant but GOD'S first

 Saint Thomas More in 1535 had such an informed conscience and therefore such a formed conscience that he knew that if the state created legislation that forced a choice between GOD and state he would choose GOD first. The State was embodied at that time in the person of King Henry VIII. Thomas More had lived his faith to the point that he had a catholic conscience. He would have been then the equivalent today of an elected politician in the government being in favour with the Prime Minister or the Taoiseach. The State ( King Henry VIII) had created a legislation which was a very serious opposition to GOD. It was against GOD'S Law and so therefore a lawless legislation. The legislation was not a small matter that could be passed over  by those catholics of mature conscience. Refusal to accept the legislation carried a penalty. It was classed as a criminal offence of High Treason against the king's person and therefore carried the then death penalty. Thomas More loved his wife and children and did not want to abandon them so he did a bit of ducking and weaving to avoid the King's wrath. He offered his resignation from his profession and livelyhood. The King initially accepted his retirement into a less well off way of life. Eventually Thomas was imprisoned and tried. Being framed he was eventually sentenced to beheading.

Thomas More is not the only person to fall foul of a state making anti-GOD legislation. There are many before him and after him. He is an excellent example to dwell on and to imitate his strength of catholic conviction in the face of persecution.
In our times ( I write this year  2012) we have seen in Ireland the Government propose anti-catholic legislation by way of demanding that Catholic Priests break the seal of confession. The pretext is to protect children. In the good ol USA,  Obama and his administration have just been re-elected. Obama had before election been promoting his Health Mandate called the HHS. Everybody knows this mandate contains legislation that is anti GOD. It asks all including catholics to use their health insurance to contribute to extermination of families and marriage by contraception; the extermination of human lifes at baby stages by legalised abortion; the genital mutilation of persons by sterilisation. A lawless legislation if ever there was. Natural law that is Law which comes from none other than GOD specifically prohibits contraception, legalised murder by abortion and mutilation by sterilisation. Now these items are not something that can be obeyed nor even supported  by an informed and maturely formed catholic conscience. The catholic Bishops in America  realise this. Failure of organisations to comply with this legislation will result in fines that accumulate and which will put them out of existence. In other words it is a means to persecute Catholics. Obama like King Henry before him has indeed made legislation which will force a choice between the state or GOD.  Should the State really be used to legislate against GOD’S law?

Turns out the majority of catholics have voted for Obama. These may very well be as someone commented 'no more than baptised pagans'. In King Henry's time too the majority of catholics just signed up to the legislation. On EWTN the catholic television network the news presenter Raymond Arroyo spoke of the catholic Vote. He had interviewed George Wiegel (philosopher and political commentator) specifically on the make up of the catholic Vote. One of the interesting questions asked was 'Do those catholics who voted for Obama realise that they just voted for their persecutor?

In our times here in Ireland the very same question could be asked of us catholics. People voted for the Irish Labour party who we all know to be anti-life in its policy. Large numbers of People voted for the Sinn Fein party who it subsequently turned out to be anti-life in Southern Ireland but lo and behold turn out to claim to be Pro-life in Northern Ireland. Do Irish Catholics realise that when they vote for these anti-life parties they vote for politics which will introduce legislation which will force them to choose between GOD and the State. Do they know that they in fact voted for their future persecutors?

Thomas More the martyr is supposed to have said at his execution 'I am the King's good servant but GOD'S first'. Are we Catholics of our time mature enough to say when the State legislates against Natural Law 'We are the State's good servants but GOD'S first'?

Friday, 30 November 2012


The Catholic Vote - 1

Is there such a thing as ‘ the Catholic Vote’?  If there is such a thing as ‘the Catholic Vote’ – what is it?  When we talk of ‘a vote’ we are pre-supposing  a Democratic system. We are referring to the political system common to societies of the West. Democratic societies like Ireland, USA, Uk, France and Germany  etc. We mean a vote which is free or un-coersed.  We vote for someone or something. The person we vote for will either be an independent politician or a member of a political party so our vote may very well support a political party. This politician and political party will have a value system or world view. We vote for a value when we vote in a referendum.
 

People vote in elections. The  election might be local, national or European. Atheists vote, Agnostics vote, Muslims vote, Jewish people vote. Christians of all denominations vote - for example Luterans vote, Anglicans vote, Baptists vote and even Catholics vote etc. What we asking is this -  among these groupings will there be a characteristic vote relative to the identity of the group? Put another way will Baptists vote in a way that is characteristic of being a Baptist? Will an atheist vote in a way that is characteristic of being an atheist? Will a Muslin vote in a way that is characteristically Muslim? And relevant to our concern here – will catholics vote in a way that is characteristically Catholic?

Well lets listen to the opinion of  Archbishop Charles J. Chaput of Philadelphia. The Archbishop gave an interview to ‘ Catholic News Service’  within two weeks of the November 2012 American presidential election. The Catholic leader clarified the duty of Catholics as he discussed the politics of abortion. He emphasized a need to honor God above country, of “Catholic identity taking precedence over everything.”

“We’re Catholics before we’re Democrats. We’re Catholics before we’re Republicans. We’re even Catholics before we’re Americans because we know that God has a demand on us prior to any government demand on us,” he said in a new interview with the wire service. “And this has been the story of the martyrs through the centuries,” Chaput said.

So taking our inspiration from this American Bishop Charles J. Chaput it would certainly appear there is indeed such a thing as a ‘Catholic Vote’.  He even give a starting point clue as to what a ‘Catholic Vote’ might be namely an ‘Honouring of GOD’. I feel those of us who are catholic voters in Ireland need to heed the advise given by this american Archbiship